Energy 2.0

Next generation nuclear and the best ideas in clean, safe power

International schemes hatch to tap nuclear for industrial heat

China, India, Russia others eyeing high temperature reactors for producing metals, hydrogen, fossil fuels, petrochemicals. Desalination too. Beijing targets 2017.

Temperature's rising: The early construction stage of China's high temperature (750-degree C) pebble bed reactor at Shidao Bay, due for grid connection in 2017. China broke ground in late 2012. Over the last month alone it has completed installation of fuel production machinery, and has successfully tested fuel pumps.

One of the most compelling reasons for the nuclear industry to start building novel reactors is that alternative designs could broaden nuclear’s clean energy appeal well beyond electricity generation and into a source of CO2-free heat that powers industrial processes.

Nuclear could usher in tremendous environmental improvements if it were to replace the CO2-spewing fossil fuels that fire up steel and cement furnaces, and that process and refine materials like petroleum, petrochemicals and hydrocarbons, just to name a few.

Industrial processes account for a huge share of the world’s energy consumption, and fossil fuels feed almost all of it. In Europe, for example, they represent a whopping 27 percent of energy use, a recent paper from Germany’s RWTH Aachen University pointed out.

If you could power those furnaces and the like with nuclear, you’d essentially knock a big heel off of the planet’s carbon footprint. Add to that the likelihood that the same reactors could help produce more clean fuels such as hydrogen and methanol, and that they could help make greater use out of coal by liquifying it or gasifying it, and you might even take off the toes as well.

As a bonus, these reactors could also desalinate water, and could assist in the production of ammonia, key for fertilizers. Oh, and they’d still produce electricity of course, only they would do so more efficiently, safely, at less cost and with less waste than conventional reactors.

Not only are you looking at an environmental clean up, but you’re also propping up energy security and human well being.

All it will take will be reactors that operate at much higher temperatures than the entrenched “light water reactors” that have essentially defined commercial nuclear power for its entire half a century run.

Whereas conventional reactors operate at around 300 degrees C, so-called “advanced” or “GenerationIV” reactors target temperatures exceeding 700 degrees, and by design extend to over 900 degrees C. They also lend themselves to small sizes that make them more affordable – manufacturers can produce them in a lower cost assembly line fashion. Users don’t have to purchase huge gigawatt-plus behemoths; rather they can settle for sub-300 megawatt capacities or less, depending on their needs.


But don’t just take my word for it.

Look at what they’re doing in China, where government companies are nearly two years into building two “pebble bed reactors” (PBR) totaling 210 megawatt (electric; 500 MW thermal) at Shidao Bay on Shandong Peninsula near Weihai City on China’s northeast coast, set for operation and grid connection by 2017. Listen to what they’re saying in Kazakhstan, where they’re talking about 950-degree C reactors for coal gasification and the production of iron, steel and hydrogen; in Indonesia, where they think 905-degree reactors might serve to produce hydrogen and desalinate water on the side (probably using “waste heat”); in South Korea, where they hope to soon begin a final feasibility study on reactors for hydrogen production and process heat; in Japan, where there’s talk of using small 950-degree C “prismatic”reactors for hydrogen production, for desalination and even for burning plutonium from Fukushima.

This and more all came into focus earlier this year, when nuclear scientists from around the world – Russia and the U.S. included – gathered in Vienna for an International Atomic Energy Agency gathering on high temperature gas cooled reactors (HTGRs) – which is just one of several reactor types vying for the high temperature superhero role.

IAEA has posted many of the country presentations from the conference on its website. By default, China’s is probably the one to read first, if for no other reason it is probably the only country that currently not only talks the talk, but also walks the walk as it constructs its 210-MWe PBR duo designed by Tsinghua University’s Institute of Nuclear and New Energy Techology (INET), based in Beijing.

“HTGR will be supplementary for electricity generation, and can be used for co-generation and process heat application,” reads the presentation from Tsinghua’s Li Fu, who notes that after 2017, China hopes to produce more of the reactors, called HTR-PM, (high temperature reactor pebble module) with “commercial deployment based on batch construction.”

Indeed, soon after China broke ground on the plant in late 2012, the website NucNet reported that the site might eventually house another 18 units of the HTR-PM, a reactor that INET said at the time “can be widely used in power generation, cogeneration and high-temperature process heat applications (and also) for oil refining, heavy oil recovery and in the chemical industry.” In recent signS of progress, a novel fan that will pump helium coolant through the reactors successfully completed testing last month, World Nuclear News reported. And earlier this month, INET said it had installed fuel production machinery for the reactors, at a remote site in Baotou, Inner Mongolia.


The HTR-PM is not to be confused with another ambitious high temperature project underway in China, in which the Chinese Academy of Sciences in Shanghai is developing small prototypes of a salt-cooled, solid fueled pebble bed reactors (Li Fu’s HTR-PM design uses gas cooling) and of a salt-cooled, liquid fueled molten salt reactor. It is targeting a 2019 completion date.

The two projects reflect a drive in China to develop nuclear power as part of an environmental and energy security push. China even has other advanced reactor projects under way. For example, it hopes to operate a “super critical water-cooled reactor” by 2025, NucNet reported. And its current commitment conventional reactors has become legendary. As I wrote recently, whereas China currently operates only 20 nuclear reactors , it has another 28 under construction, an additional 58 planned, and a staggering 150 or so proposed.

It is also stepping up as an exporter of nuclear reactors and technologies to countries including Saudi Arabia and possibly the UK. Its penchant for selling abroad applies not only to conventional reactors, but to advanced reactors as well. In one of his Vienna slides, Tshinghua’s Li noted that the HTR-PM is “suitable for international market” and that its small size makes it “more flexible for developing countries.”

There should be plenty of opportunities for foreign activity, as evidenced by the IAEA Vienna gathering:

  • A joint German presentation from Germany’s RWTH Aachen University and research group Jülich Forschungszentrum (the same presentation that noted that Europe consumes 27 percent of its energy in industrial processes), noted possibilities for ammonia synthesis in Spain and aluminum production in South Africa.
  • Kazakhstan, which is working with Japan on development of a high temperature gas-cooled reactors, noted in a presentation by Irina Tazhibayeva from the country’s Nuclear Technology Safety Center that it hopes to commission a high temperature reactor generating electricity and producing hydrogen by 2027. It also candidly pointed out some of the technical and financial challenges.
  • Japan itself has a small, 30-MW prismatic gas-cooled high reactor that has hit temperatures of 950 degrees C. The country foresees using it for among other purposes hydrogen production and for burning plutonium from Fukushima. It envisions using thorium at some point, according to its Vienna presentation. The World Nuclear Assocation reports that Japan is proposping a 100-MW demonstartion plant for the United Arab Emirates.
  • Russia also has a high temperature gas cooled project called the GT-MHR, based on a design by General Atomics in the U.S. and dating back to an international project in the 1990s and calling for a gas turbine rather than one driven by steam. Its future is unclear (Russia is committed to liquid sodium cooled fast reactors that are not as high temperature as the GT-MHR) but the developers at Moscow’s Kurchatov Institute have a vision for several applications, one being disposal of plutonium (the reactor would burn it). In his Vienna paper Kurchatov’s Peter Fomichenko emphasized that Russia’s developers “currently see the mission of HTGRs not so much in generation of electricity, but mostly in production of high-temperature heat and hydrogen.” His presentation rattled off potential users, noting the oil recovery industry, petrochemical industry, ammonia synthesis, metallurgy and synthetic fuel.

India, too, has shown high-level interest. When Prime Minister Narendra Modi visited the country’s renowned Babha Atomic Research Center in July, he discussed the possibility of using high temperature reactors for hydrogen production, India’s Business Standard reported.

Many of these ideas and designs go back to the 1940s and have wound their way through the U.S., Germany and other countries through the decades. In South Africa, Steenkampskraal Thorium Ltd is trying to get a gas-cooled PBR off the ground. In the U.S., San Diego-based General Atomics’ EM2 gas-cooled reactor with a gas turbine shows great promise, operating at 850 degrees by design with a fuel that in principle could withstand temperatures about 3 times that high, greatly reducing the chance of accidents.


A lot of the world’s high temperature projects are, however, at a financing impasse. In the U.S., work by the Department of Energy’s Idaho National Laboratories has slowed down to the point where the government’s financial watchdog, the Government Accountability Office, recently warned that DOE looks likely to miss a 2021 deadline for building a prototype high temperature gas-cooled reactor. The DOE blames a lack of industry funding. In a Catch-22, industry also blames a lack of funding.

Meanwhile, development of other high temperature reactor technologies, like molten salt reactors, could rise to the occasion, although they face similar funding challenges.

Potential stakeholders are interested, but only up to a point. The Next Generation Nuclear Power (NGNP) Industry Alliance, a U.S.-based group that works with DOE’s Idaho National Laboratory and is committed to developing high temperature gas reactors, includes potential users like Dow Chemical, ConocoPhilips and the Petroleum Technology Alliance Canada as members. Yet INL, for all its advances – it has proven fuel integrity at 1800 degrees C – is unable to secure the money that would enable them to build a protype by 2021.

All eyes on China’s Shandong Peninsula, where things are really heating up. Deservedly, Weihei will host the next biannual International Topical Meeting on High Temperature Reactor Technology, this Oct 27-31, organized by Tshinghua’s INET.

It should be a sizzling show. That’s the end of the puns, but it’s certainly not the end of this story. Get ready for nuclear heat.

Photo is a screen grab from the Institute of Nuclear and New Energy Technology’s (Tsinghua University) announcement of the upcoming HTR2014 conference, Oct. 27-31.

Nuclear’s powerful punch should wallop fossil fuels – take it from a renowned oil man

No energy source comes close to the density of uranium or thorium

Oil at a peak: Fossil fuels don't have anywhere near the energy content of nuclear. "Peak Oil" theorist M. King Hubbert pointed that out as far back as 1956.

Over recent months, this blog has delivered nuclear industry news noting among other things the bustling growth of reactor construction in China, the percolating activity in non-traditionally nuclear regions of the world like Southeast Asia, the Middle East and Africa, and the emerging British interest in small reactors. In today’s installment, we will take a breather from current affairs and instead opt for a little pro-nuclear history lesson. A nuclear

Continue reading…

China, Canada jointly ratchet up thorium, alternative fuels for CANDU reactors

Could build for other countries too. Argentina and Romania next?

Used fuel and thorium are already part of the mix at the Qinshan CANDU reactors in China.

Once again, leave it to China to demonstrate that the future of nuclear could well reside in reactor technologies that are notably different from the conventional reactors that have defined the industry forever. And in China’s most recent example, throw in another country that itself is emerging as a leader in alternative nuclear: Canada. State and private-sector entities from the two countries in late July signed a memorandum of understanding

Continue reading…

ExxonMobil: Nuclear power will double

Yes, ExxonMobil. Shell sees growth too. The oil companies know that nuclear is clean.

Nuclear nights: Nuclear will increasingly keep the world's lights on as countries like China continue to grow and turn to cleaner energy sources. Above, Shanghai's Pudong district.

Let’s start this week’s blog with a quiz. Identify the source of this global prediction: “By 2040, we expect that the use of nuclear power will approximately double.” Is it: a) a leading utility; b) a large nuclear company; c) one of those growing crop of greenies clamoring for nuclear to help staunch the spewing of environmentally ruinous carbon dioxide (we like those folks here at Energy 2.0); d) a

Continue reading…

UK prepared to regulate small modular reactors

Country’s chief nuclear inspector tells Parliament that the time for approval should be no more than with conventional models

Lakeside revival: The disused Trawsfynydd nuclear site on a lake in northern Wales could come alive again as a site for a small modular reactor.

The time it would take to approve and license a small modular reactor in the UK would be no longer than the time it takes with a conventional large reactor, the country’s’ chief nuclear inspector assured Parliament this week. The testimony from Andy Hall, chief nuclear inspector at the Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR), should allay concerns that the regulator might be ill-prepared to review SMR applications. Regulatory processes in

Continue reading…

Experts to Parliament: Small reactors can boost UK nuclear 

Deploy them in altogether new locations for huge leap in clean affordable energy they say, as House of Commons “SMR” hearings  continue

Industrial Strength: Dr. Fiona Rayment of the UK's National Nuclear Laboratory told a House of Commons select committee that small modular reactors could operate on an industrial user's site and thus reduce reliance on the grid and on fossil fuels.

Industrial electricity users who want to reduce their reliance on the grid and on volatile fossil fuels could install small modular nuclear reactors on their site to ensure a constant electricity supply, an expert has advised a UK Parliamentary committee that is investigating the potential uses for alternative nuclear power in Britain. The novel reactors would thus help significantly increase nuclear electricity’s share of the country’s energy mix said the

Continue reading…

Alternative reactors go to Parliament

Uses include district heating and hydrogen production, experts testify to a UK House of Commons committee

Stein's way: Testifying to a House committee, Rolls-Royce's Paul Stein noted that the nuclear industry does not exactly progress at the pace of “greased lightning.” But it could develop an SMR for Britain within 7 years if it initially sticks with shrunken conventional designs before trying advanced models, he said.

Small, alternative reactors could open up British nuclear power to entirely new uses such as district heating and hydrogen production, and thus buoy the country’s efforts to meet mandatory carbon reduction goals. So testified experts backed by Rolls-Royce, by utilities and even by the fossil fuel industry when asked by a Parliamentary committee about the potential for small modular reactors (SMRs). “We look at the question in the context of

Continue reading…

Nuclear will keep the home fires burning in China

Beijing practices what it preaches as it campaigns to export reactors

Raising the temperature: China's nuclear expansion includes the development of small high temperature reactors that will provide heat for industrial processes. Jiang Mianheng, who is the son of former Chinese president Jiang Zemin, heads a Shanghai high temperature project for the Chinese Academy of Sciences.

In recent blogs, we’ve pointed out how nuclear reactor companies are turning to seemingly unlikely geographies for growth. Southeast Asia, the Middle East, Africa and South America – hardly traditional nuclear markets – look set to help revive the nuclear renaissance that stalled following the meltdowns at Japan’s Fukushima plant in March, 2011. We’ve also noted that China and its state-owned reactor companies are among the nuclear purveyors chasing business

Continue reading…

China steps up nuclear ties with Arab world

Non-western and developing nations turn to the East and Russia for maiden voyages into atomic energy. The West likes them too – London calling!

Chinese president Xi Jinping, pictured with U.S. Barack Obama during March's Nuclear Security Summit in Holland, wants to help the Arab world achieve “high tech breakthroughs in nuclear energy.”

Welcome to the new growth curve of nuclear power: While developed countries like Germany, Japan and the U.S. either walk away or dither over their commitment to atomic energy, non-Western and developing nations are turning to it in droves, often tapping Russia, China and the East as their provider.

UK government-industry body seeks proposals for alternative nuclear

Public-private investment group including BP, Shell and Rolls-Royce says small reactors could trump large conventional designs and help meet CO2 reduction goals

The future of nuclear? Royal Dutch Shell is part of a British public-private investment group that is seeking proposals for small modular reactors.

A key low carbon public-private British investment group that includes oil and turbine companies BP, Shell, Rolls-Royce and Caterpillar is casting its net into nuclear, seeking proposals for alternative reactors that depart from conventional designs and that could serve as a source of both electricity and heat. The request for proposals (RFP) from the Energy Technologies Institute (ETI) marks a widening of the group’s interests beyond the renewables and fossil-fuel

Continue reading…

How do you finally get nuclear fusion to work? One answer: Crowdfund it!

New Jersey company taps modern, free financing in the chase of energy’s Holy Grail

Out with the copper, in with the beryllium: Eric Lerner (left) examines the copper electrodes on his fusion machine. With crowdfunding, he hopes to replace them with beryllium versions.

If you play a game of word association with the phrase “nuclear fusion,” chances are someone will shout out, “always forty years in the future”(maybe they’d say “thirty” but you get the point) and, “expensive.” Fusion, the elusive Holy Grail energy technology, has remained decades away ever since physicists seriously began positing it in the 1950s as a clean, safe, plentiful power source. It can indeed carry a hefty price

Continue reading…

New frontiers for nuclear include Africa – and not just for electricity

Could the continent start hosting novel reactors?

Lagos, Nigeria is Africa's largest city with about 21 million people. It and the rapidly growing country lack adequate electricity and clean water. Nuclear power looks poised to help.

It is becoming a trend: As countries from the developed world prevaricate over nuclear power, the technology is gaining favor in underdeveloped nations and other places where you might not expect it as a source of desperately needed clean, steady, low-carbon electricity. Want proof?  Just look at the last week’s headlines from Africa alone, where three countries – Nigeria, Kenya and Algeria – all made moves toward establishing their first

Continue reading…

Indonesia’s nuclear future: Electricity, clean water and – Bill Gates?

A low-CO2 model for other countries too

The greening of Kalimantan: Lush Indonesia generates close to 90 percent of its electricity from coal, oil and natural gas. It needs a lot more power to sustain its economic growth, and it's looking toward nuclear, which could power smelters and desalination in places like Kalimantan (above).

Nuclear energy developer Bill Gates – better known as software billionaire and philanthropist Bill Gates – is reportedly mulling a proposal to build his novel reactor for Indonesia, and while a deal looks unlikely, the prospect underscores how nuclear is poised for a pivotal transition towards not only superior new reactor technologies, but also to new markets and innovative uses of the clean energy source. Gates, who is chairman of

Continue reading…